google-site-verification: googleb00a8ae6152413a4.html

Dazzling Wedding Cakes - 8 Beyond Talented Pennsylvania Cake Experts

Sponsored: I am so excited to partner with each of these amazing vendors for this post!



You're going to love this article if you're in Pennsylvania. We've gathered some seriously talented cake artists to consider for your wedding day. Prepare to be dazzled when you see their work... yes, it's seriously that good.

Featured Cake Experts

Cake Shotts - Dayton, PA

Custom Cakes by Jen - Hanover, PA

Katie Cakes Cakery - Cleona, PA

The Master's Baker - Chester, PA

The Perfect Cake - Chambersburg, PA

Bella's Desserts - Glenmoore, PA

Amy's Creative Cakes - Quakertown, PA

Psycho Cupcakes - Newville, PA

Getting married in Pennsylvania? The Cake is Kind of a Big Deal.

Check out these talented local bakers. Scroll through photos, meet the talent and schedule a consultation! Get excited, it's time for flowers!

(listed in completely random order! - they were all SO fabulous to work with!)


#1 Psycho Cupcakes - Newville, PA

We're Interviewing: Nicole, Owner/Cake Artist

What areas do you service?

I service Central Pennsylvania, including Harrisburg, Camp Hill, Mechanicsburg, Dillsburg, Enola, Carlisle, Chambersburg, Shippensburg, Newville – and everywhere in between.

Do you have a favorite flavor?

I am an industrial sized fan of dark chocolate. My personal favorite cake and icing combination is Death by Chocolate: Rich double chocolate cake layered and masked with smooth and creamy Callebaut Dark Chocolate ganache. Then over-poured and drizzled with melted ganache and decorated with chocolate sprinkles and dark chocolate curls.

What is the most popular flavor?

My most popular cake flavors are French Toast and S’mores. My French Toast cupcake is perfect for day/brunch weddings! Delicious cinnamon sugar and maple syrup top the Italian Vanilla Bean Buttercream that accompanies the soft and fluffy French Toast cupcake. And my S’mores cupcake is as close as you can get to the real thing! My graham cracker cupcake is filled with dark chocolate ganache, then topped with a Toasted Marshmallow Italian Meringue. A true ooey gooey s’more-sy experience!

Do you have a favorite cake you've done in the past?

There are too many factors in determining a favorite cake, so here are my top 3 wedding cakes. One of my first Halloween weddings the couple requested a haunted house cake. It had broken shutters, a black chocolate ‘iron’ fence, a wonky door, skeletons, pumpkins, creepy trees, oh my. I remember it being so much fun building and watching the cake come to life with my team! A few years ago, another awesome opportunity came my way in the form of a Sleeping Beauty inspired Castle Cake. I was immediately on board and sketching a design. It had gumpaste stone walls, pulled sugar thorns surrounding the castle, and cute pink flags atop the spires. The bride’s reaction was exactly what I had hoped for – she was stunned! And finally, this past year I created an utterly unique cake that showed off the couples love of sci-fi. The cake had Circular Gallifreyan text, the white tree of Gondor, a Labrador patronus, and did I mention a DRAGON?! Hours and hours of labored love flew by while creating this wedding cake. It is challenging, but also a lot of fun when couples give me artistic freedom to take their ideas and cake-itize them. I am looking very much forward to creating my next ‘favorite’ cake!

Do you offer delivery?

Delivery and setup are available for all wedding cakes.

Do you offer anything besides wedding cakes?

Apart from cakes and cupcakes, I do offer a variety of other tasty treats that are perfect for a dessert table or as yummy parting gifts for your guests. These items include cakepops, chocolate covered strawberries, cakesicles, chocolate caramel pretzel sticks, chocolate chip cookies, salted caramel chocolate chip cookies, sugar cookies, personalized/decorated sugar cookies, butter cookies, oatmeal raisin cookies, meringue cookies, and meringue cookie pops.

Nicole, can you show us some other photos?

What can I expect at a consultation?

I am a home-based business. I conduct all wedding cake tastings and consultations in my home in Newville, PA 17241.

What's next?

So, you’re thinking of going PSYCHO? Wonderful! Then it’s time to schedule a virtual or face-to-face wedding consultation today by following this link:

Psycho Cupcakes

Phone: 717.766.7295


Instagram @psych0cupcakes

Pinterest @PsychoCupcakesPA

Facebook @PsychoCupcakesLLC


#2 Amy's Creative Cakes - Quakertown, PA

We're Interviewing: Amy Recinos, Owner & Pastry Chef

What areas do you service?

We service Lehigh Valley, Bucks county , Berks County, Montgomery County and surrounding areas.

What is your favorite flavor?

My favorite cake is Chocolate with Chocolate Espresso Filling or Pomegranate Filling.

What is the most popular flavor?

Our all season best seller is the Cinnamon Swirl Cake with Cinnamon Cream Cheese Filling or Cinnamon buttercream Filling.

Do you have a favorite cake you've done?

Photo Synthesis

Do you deliver?

We do deliver our wedding cakes and larger orders and corporate orders

Amy, can you show us some photos?

Do you offer anything besides wedding cakes?

Yes, we have many sweet offerings! Such as dessert displays that include cookies, brownies, cupcakes and cake truffles as well as homemade marshmallows. In addition we offer cupcake towers and several styles cupcake display options. Our edible favors include custom cookies, cake pops and cake truffles.

Get in touch!

Amy's Creative Cakes

2045 Valley View Drive, Quakertown PA 18951

Phone number is 215-529-5763

Instagram link - @amyscreativecakes


#3 Bella's Desserts - Glenmoore, PA

We're Interviewing: Lauren, Owner & Baker

What Areas Do You Service?

Southeast Pennsylvania, Southern New Jersey, Northern Delaware, Northern Maryland

What Are Your Most Favorite Cake & Icing Flavors?

My favorite is my Sweet and Salty cake. It’s chocolate cake with salted caramel chocolate ganache and salted caramel filling, with a sprinkle of Fleur De Sel, and salted caramel Swiss meringue buttercream, yum! All from scratch of course!

What is the Most Popular Flavor?

Of course vanilla, but chocolate chip and marble are close seconds.

Do You Have a Favorite Cake You’ve Done in the Past?

This by far was the most difficult and most satisfying cake. It is the Enterprise from Star Trek: Wrath of Khan for a 50th birthday. The couple rented out a movie theater to show the film and invited me to attend. Great fun and the first structured cake I ever made.

Do you Deliver?

I do deliver. My fees are based on time and mileage round trip.

Do You Offer Anything Besides Wedding Cakes?

I offer almost everything desserts! From cakes an cupcakes, to mini desserts, and highly decorated cookies.

Lauren, can you show us some photos?

What's next?

Schedule a cake tasting and consultation by giving us a call today! Show us pictures of cakes you like the most, and together we’ll design your perfect wedding cake.)

Get In Touch!

Bella's Desserts

Home Based Bakery

Glenmoore, PA near Chester Springs


FB: @bellasdesserts

IG: @bellasdesserts


#4 The Perfect Cake - Chambersburg, PA

We're Interviewing: Cindy, Master Sugar Artist, Owner & Operator

What areas do you service?

I’ve served the south central Pennsylvania and northern MD region since 1994.

All my custom flavors are made fresh to order. I have a large variety to select from including favorites like pink champagne, coconut crème, orange vanilla crème, white toasted almond, lemon poppyseed and chocolate chocolate chip! While I specialize in fondant creations, underneath it all can still be delicious favorites like fluffy buttercreams, genaches and delicious fillings. Every design should always taste as good as it looks.

What flavor seems to be the most popular?

Most popular is tricky as everyone has particular taste but over the years my white toasted almond cake with chocolate ganache filling has set the standard in my area. Personally, I’m a sucker for basic white wedding cake.

Do you have a favorite cake you've done in the past?

My most recent favorite cake I made was for my best friend’s daughter. She gave me free reign to create this gold/coral, all edible, masterpiece for her wedding which included layers of chocolate chocolate chip cake with peanut butter buttercream filling, coconut crème cake with marshmallow filling, white toasted almond cake with chocolate ganache filling and a lemon berry creme cake. (It’s the image of the 5 tier cake with the completely gold layer.) The cake matched her evening wedding to perfection!

Cindy, can you show us some photos?

Do you deliver?

Delivery is available and pricing is determined by the distance.

Do you offer anything besides wedding cakes?

In addition to cakes I offer decorated mini cakes, cupcakes and cake pops

What's next?

I am a state licensed, home based custom cake designer. Consultations and tastings are by appointment only. You can contact me with inquires at:

Get in touch!

The Perfect Cake

Contact: Cindy Lepo


2810 Lawyer Rd., Chambersburg, PA 17201

ig: the.perfectcake


#5 The Master's Baker - Chester, PA

We're Interviewing: Danielle, Lead Cake Designer

What Areas Do You Service?

From Philadelphia, The Main Line, Lancaster County , Delaware and even Baltimore!

What Are Your Most

Favorite Cake & Icing Flavors?

Rich Dark Chocolate with TMB Traditional Buttercream, can't beat it!

What is the Most Popular Flavor?

This is hard to choose, we have quite a few, but people really seem to love our Pink Champagne and our Red Velvet cakes right now. Every season brings a new and popular flavor.

Do You Have a Favorite Cake You’ve Done in the Past?

We have done so many amazing cakes over our 50+ years in business, although more recent, this is one our whole team worked on and we can all collectively say we are very proud of. This couple was so great to work with, with a whole harry potter wedding theme!

Danielle, can you show us some photos?

Do you Deliver?

Yes! Pricing depends on how many miles you or your venue is located from the shop.

Do You Offer Anything Besides Wedding Cakes?

We have an incredible pastry chef who comes up with a delicious array of desserts each season. We offer anything from cupcakes, to dessert verrines, cream puffs and cannolis, to french macarons and decorated cookies!

What’s Next?

If you are a bride who is looking for a truly custom cake experience, from beginning, up until your big day, please contact us by heading to our website, where you can schedule your appointment to talk with our wedding cake consultant. There you will discuss what you are looking for in your perfect wedding cake, share some photos, and taste 7 of our most popular cake flavors along with fillings as well!

Get in touch!

The Master's Baker

We are located at 319 West Gay Street West

Chester, PA 19380





#6 Katie Cakes Cakery - Cleona, PA

We're Interviewing: Katie, Owner

What areas do you service?

We are in home licensed bakery located in Cleona, Pennsylvania. We service Lebanon, Lancaster, Hershey, Harrisburg and surrounding areas.

Do you have a favorite flavor?

My favorite flavor would either be our carrot cake with cream cheese icing or applesauce cake with cinnamon buttercream. Both cakes are family recipes we grew up enjoying!

What is a popular flavor among clients?

I would say the chocolate cake with salted caramel buttercream or our cinnamon bun cake would be the most popular.

Do you have a favorite cake you've done in the past?

Yes, here is my favorite cake I made from 2014.

Katie, can you show us some photos?

Do you deliver?

Yes, we deliver! Typically up to an hour from Cleona, Pennsylvania but feel free to inquire for other locations.

Do you offer anything besides wedding cakes?

We offer cupcakes, cake pops, dessert and candy tables as well as cakes for all sorts of occasions.

What's Next?

We would love the opportunity to discuss creating your dream wedding cake and desserts! Please contact us to set up a consultation and cake tasting and to discuss the next steps.

Get in touch!

Katie Cakes Cakery



#7 Custom Cakes by Jen - Hanover, PA

We're Interviewing: Jennifer, Pastry Chef & Owner

What areas do you service?

Central PA and Northern Maryland

What is your favorite flavor?

My favorites would be white cake with coconut custard and German chocolate

Is there a most popular flavor?

Most popular are white with fresh strawberry filling or raspberry marmalade, also strawberry champagne and red velvet.

Do you deliver?

I do deliver weddings over 75 guests. Smaller weddings are available for pickup at my stand at the Markets at Hanover.

I can answer specific delivery questions at

Do you have a favorite cake you've done in the past?

Yes, here's the photo!

Do you offer anything besides wedding cakes?

Also available are cupcakes, cake pops, cheesecake, and a wide variety of miniature desserts.

Jen, can you show us some photos?

What's Next?

Tasting/consultation appointments are available on Sundays at the Markets at Hanover. It is a nominal $20 charge, which comes off the cost of your cake if you book with me. Please contact me by email or through my website with any questions or to schedule an appointment.

Get in touch!

Custom Cakes by Jen

at the Markets at Hanover

1649 Broadway, Hanover, PA 17331

Website -



#8 Cake Shotts - Dayton, PA

We're Interviewing: Jessica, Owner & Operator

What areas do you service?

Western Pennsylvania

What are your favorite cake and icing flavors?

My personal favorite is chocolate with peanut butter. Our most popular flavor is white almond with raspberry and chocolate/peanut butter is a close second.

Do you offer anything besides wedding cakes?

We offer wedding cookies, macarons, cupcakes and cake pops.

Jessica, can you show us some photos?

Get In Touch!

Cake Shotts

1574 State Rte 1042, Dayton, PA 16222

Phone: (724) 954-0161



You May Also Like:

10 Ways to Start Preparing to be the Most Gorgeous Bride, Ever!

It Rained on My Wedding Day, Here's Why It Was Amazing

Don't Make These 9 Wedding Mistakes (be nice to your mom!)

Should You Do a First Look? My Experience & What I Would Change

18 GORGEOUS Engagement Rings + Get a Replica/Sample in the Mail!


What is my relationship to the featured wedding vendors? I am always transparent with my audience. These vendors were hand selected by me to feature in this post. They were each charged a small fee to cover my time in creating their feature as this provides a means for me to earn an income. I reached out to them and offered the opportunity, they did not seek me out looking to advertise. I only feature venues and vendors I truly think are great!

This post and it’s contents are for educational purposes only. While I believe all of these vendors are wonderful to consider, I am just a blogger and am not responsible for your personal experiences by any feature vendor or venue on this website. We were given permission by the vendor to use the content/photos they submitted to us. The vendor is responsible for any required photographer credits and only submitting content they have permission to use.

By using this website, you agree to the Terms of Service, Disclaimers, Disclosures and Terms of Use easily found on the footer of this website.